From identifying “enemies” and monitoring diaspora to manipulating local organizations, Beijing is using every means in its toolbox to silence those among the Chinese community in Canada it views as threats, a government report alleges.
The report, obtained by Global News and reported on Jan. 26, alleged that China is actively engaged in a “systematic campaign of intelligence-gathering, persuasion, influence, and manipulation” against dissident voices through its Overseas Chinese Affairs Office (OCAO).
The OCAO, which the Chinese regime claims “protect[s] the legitimate rights and interests of overseas Chinese,” was tasked with “influencing or manipulating” community members and using “coercive tactics” against those who challenged the regime, according to the report.
“This involves intimidation of OC (Overseas Chinese) at every level of society,” said the report, released by the Canada Border Security Agency (CBSA) in March 2020.
“The managing of their behaviour is accomplished through incentive or disincentive, as well as intelligence-gathering, surveillance, and subversion against OC communities.”
The CBSA report added that the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) seeks to eliminate any perceived overseas threats to its power, such as from Taiwan independence advocates and Falun Gong adherents, and relies on the OCAO, which is established “in almost every country to personally liaise with local OC communities.”
According to Global News, the report was disclosed during a recent court case involving former OCAO employee Yong Zhang and his spouse Yuxia Gao, who were both denied permanent residency in Canada when their appeal was dismissed by the Federal Court on Jan. 19.
In her ruling, Justice Vanessa Rochester wrote that while the couple was sponsored by their daughter, who is a naturalized citizen, a Canadian immigration officer in Hong Kong had deemed them inadmissible due to Zhang’s previous employment with OCAO.
“The Officer determined that there were reasonable grounds to believe that OCAO had engaged in acts of espionage that are ‘contrary to Canada’s interests,’” she wrote.
Zhang’s lawyer Jacqueline Bonisteel told Global News that her client was never alleged to have engaged in spying for China; he was just a low-level member of an organization Canada accused of espionage.
“He had no personal involvement, he is not a spy,” Bonisteel said.
The judge noted Zhang was a computer technician from 1983 until 2002, at which time he was transferred to an administrative position. She wrote in her ruling that Immigration Canada noted by the time Zhang retired in 2004, he was a “chief staff member.”
The CBSA report shares a similar conclusion with the immigration officer as it makes the case that OCAO “engages in espionage” and “is known to operate in Canada.”
“The OCAO is involved in covert action and coercion against OC communities and other minorities around the world by targeting Chinese dissidents overseas, and engaging in intelligence gathering on OC and their activities,” it said.
“The OCAO works to undermine individuals identified as threats to the CPC (Communist Party of China), and it organizes and monitors ‘overseas Chinese business, student, cultural, media, and political networks.’”
The CBSA report, which quoted from the U.S. government, academic journals, and news accounts, according to Global News, said the Chinese intelligence services were among the “most active” in the world, and were “becoming more aggressive.”
“Although estimates on the number of spies vary, it has been reported that ‘China can rightly claim to have the world’s largest, most amorphous, but also most active intelligence sector … as any Chinese, especially those from China, from student to CEO, are potential active intelligence assets,’” it said.
Sheng Xue, a Chinese-Canadian democracy activist in Toronto, said the deep and entrenched pro-Beijing elements planted by the CCP threaten national security not just in Canada.
“The threat and infiltration of the CCP has formed a networked mode of action in democratic countries. As long as there are incidents that are not conducive to the CCP, the organizations and personnel assigned by the CCP in these countries will take immediate measures,” she said in a previous interview with The Epoch Times.
Gloria Fung, president of Canada-Hong Kong Link, said apart from attempting to silence the business, cultural, and media sectors in Canada, the CCP is also actively looking to muzzle any politicians who are outspoken about the regime’s brutality and misconduct.
She cited the example of former Conservative MP Kenny Chiu who lost his seat in the B.C. riding of Steveston–Richmond East in the 2021 federal election.
“They have also interfered with the democratic integrity of the country in the recent federal election by spreading fake news about Kenny Chiu’s Bill C-282, saying that it will lead to discrimination or racism towards the Chinese Canadians,” Fung said in a previous interview.
Bill C-282 is a private member’s bill that seeks to compel those working on behalf of foreign entities to register as foreign agents in order to increase transparency.
Chiu told The Epoch Times in a previous interview that he has been a target of misinformation in previous election campaigns, but in 2021, “it has been exceptional.”
Both the Canadian Security Intelligence Service and the National Security and Intelligence Committee of Parliamentarians, a special parliamentary committee, had published reports warning of increasing threats by foreign state actors against Canada’s national security.
The CBSA report says Beijing will stop at nothing to eliminate “rival discourse or potential threats” to its existence.
“The OCAO is focused on the elimination of threats to the regime and it seeks to undermine those threats in the countries in which it operates,” it said.
Noé Chartier contributed to this report