US News

Arizona Lawmakers Rebuke Report Advocating Removal of Firearms from Homes with Children


Representatives Quang Nguyen and Selina Bliss argue that the proposal represents a blatant infringement on Second Amendment rights.

A legislative report from Arizona addressing child fatalities, which recommends the removal of all firearms from homes with children, has faced backlash from two lawmakers, who claim it violates Second Amendment rights.

Republican Reps. Quang Nguyen and Selina Bliss voiced their concerns about the Arizona Child Fatality Review Team’s 2023 annual report to the Legislature in a letter addressed to Jennie Cunico, the executive officer for the Arizona Department of Health Services.
The report indicates that 853 children lost their lives in Arizona in 2023, with local CFRP review teams determining that 49 percent of these tragedies were “preventable.”

The leading causes of these preventable deaths included motor vehicle accidents, firearm injuries, suffocation, fentanyl overdoses, and drowning.

“In 2023, 68 children died due to firearm injuries, marking an alarming 171 percent increase in child firearm-related deaths over the past decade,” noted the report.

All 68 firearm-related fatalities in 2023 were classified as preventable according to the report.

“The CFRP concluded that access to firearms is the most substantial risk factor for firearm-related deaths; therefore, they believe the most effective means to mitigate these deaths is to eliminate all firearms from homes with children, as the presence of guns notably increases the risk of adolescent suicides.

“It is crucial for all parents with teenagers to eliminate guns from their households, particularly if there is a history of mental health issues or substance abuse.”

“Furthermore, the CFRP suggests that all gun owners practice safe storage by keeping firearms unloaded and securely locked separately from ammunition.”

In their correspondence with ADHS, Nguyen and Bliss described the CFRT’s findings as a “radical assault on the constitutional rights of Arizonans,” drawing parallels with state attempts to undermine Second Amendment protections.

The representatives noted that this proposal echoes New Mexico Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham’s 2023 gun control order, which sought to prohibit the public carrying of firearms for self-defense.

“We are outraged that the CFRT, representing the Arizona Department of Health Services, is advocating for the curtailment of Arizonans’ Second Amendment rights in their own residences,” the lawmakers asserted.

As the chair of Arizona’s House Judiciary Committee, Nguyen emphasized, “Proposals that aim to disarm citizens are not only unconstitutional but also devoid of common sense.”

“While the report proposes sensible safety measures concerning other risks, like drowning, the CFRT overreaches by suggesting the complete removal of firearms from homes with children.”

Both lawmakers affirmed that effective policy solutions to complex issues should safeguard constitutional rights rather than diminish them.

Pew Research Center data reveals that between 2019 and 2021, the incidence of gun fatalities among children and teenagers in the U.S. surged by 50 percent.

In 2019, prior to the COVID-19 pandemic, there were 1,732 gun-related deaths involving minors under 18, with that figure escalating to 2,590 by 2021.

These minors lost their lives through diverse means, including suicides, accidental shootings, and homicides, as indicated in the report.

The RAND Gun Policy in America initiative shows that as of January 1, 2024, 35 states and the District of Columbia had enacted Child-Access Prevention (CAP) laws.

Regardless of a child’s ability to access or use a firearm, the strictest laws impose penalties for negligent storage.



Source link

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.