Ex-CNBC Analyst Pleads Guilty to Defrauding Investors of Nearly $3 Million
James Arthur McDonald generated millions from clients but diverted a significant portion for personal investments and payments to earlier investors resembling a Ponzi scheme.
Former CNBC financial analyst James Arthur McDonald is staring at a lengthy prison sentence after reportedly defrauding investors of at least $2.7 million, according to an announcement from the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) on February 19.
McDonald, 53, a past resident of Arcadia, California, has agreed to plead guilty to one charge of securities fraud, a felony that could result in a maximum prison term of 20 years.
“This defendant was entrusted by his clients to handle their funds and breached that trust by using it to benefit himself,” stated acting U.S. Attorney Joseph McNally.
During the raid at his hideout, agents discovered a fraudulent Washington, D.C. driver’s license displaying McDonald’s photo but bearing the name “Brian Thomas,” as reported by the U.S. Attorney’s Office in Los Angeles.
McDonald served as the CEO and chief investment officer of two Los Angeles-based firms—Hercules Investments LLC and Index Strategy Advisors Inc. He was a frequent contributor on the CNBC financial news network.
Related Stories
In late 2020, federal authorities indicated that McDonald incurred substantial losses for Hercules clients, amounting to tens of millions, after assuming a risky short position that essentially bet against the U.S. economy’s stability following the presidential election.
McDonald anticipated that the COVID-19 pandemic and the election would trigger significant market sell-offs leading to a downturn; however, that market decline never occurred, leading to client losses estimated between $30 million and $40 million.
By December 2020, complaints from Hercules clients about their losses began to surface, as documented in court filings.
The seal of the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) at its headquarters in Washington on May 12, 2021. The SEC filed civil charges against James Arthur McDonald, Jr., in 2022, accusing him of violating federal securities law. Reuters/Andrew Kelly/File Photo
Moreover, he failed to inform clients about the significant losses the company had already experienced, as indicated by the U.S. Attorney’s Office in Los Angeles.
In an effort to raise capital, McDonald secured $675,000 in investment funds from one group of victims on March 9, 2021, but misappropriated most of these funds in various ways, including expenditures of $179,610 at a Porsche dealership and a transfer of $109,512 to the landlord of a rental property he occupied in Arcadia.
Prosecutors also allege that McDonald defrauded clients of his other firm, Index Strategy Advisors Inc., by utilizing less than half of approximately $3.6 million he claimed to have raised for trading. Instead, he regularly mixed client funds with personal bank account funds, which he then used to purchase luxury vehicles, pay for his home rent, settle personal credit card payments, and cover operating expenses of Hercules.
Additionally, prosecutors claimed that he made Ponzi-like payments to clients of his companies.
Overall, McDonald is said to have caused losses ranging from about $2.7 million to over $3 million, according to federal prosecutors.
In April 2024, U.S District Judge Percy Anderson found McDonald and Hercules guilty and ordered them to pay civil penalties and several million dollars in disgorgement, which requires relinquishing any ill-gotten gains.
