Key Virginia Congressional Contest a Battle of Who Supports Police More

As polls close on Nov. 8 and election night results unscroll east to west, eyes countrywide will be watching two Virginia congressional district races analysts say are bellwether contests presaging which party will win the day and control the U.S. House in 2023.

According to Cook Partisan Voting Index (CPVI), Virginia’s Congressional District 2 (CD 2) and CD 7 are among 22 congressional districts nationwide occupied by incumbent Democrats in fall races rated as “tossups.” 

The GOP has targeted the two commonwealth districts—and its underdog candidate is making a competitive run in a third—in its goal to flip the Virginia congressional delegation’s 7-4 Democratic majority into, at least, a 6-5 Republican advantage.

Doing so would also notch two of the five seats Republicans must gain on Nov. 8 to secure a Midterm majority in the U.S. House. That is why eyes will be watching as results in Virginia’s CD 2 and CD 7 unfold.

All 11 Virginia congressional incumbents are defending their seats in November. Eight of the sitting reps, including all four GOP House members, are expected to convincingly win additional two-year terms in the fall.

Democratic incumbent Rep. Abigail Spanberger (D-Va,) speaks to a class of trade apprentices at the IBEW Local 26 Training Center in Northern Virginia during a recent campaign visit. (Courtesy of Abigail Spanberger for Congress)

Three Democrats, however, all two-term incumbents, face stiff challenges in bids to retain their seats in Congress. 

Rep. Elaine Luria (D-Va.) in CD 2 and Rep. Abigail Spanberger (D-Va.) in CD 7, are in projected nail-biters. GOP first-time candidate Hung Cao is, meanwhile, giving Rep. Jennifer Wexton (D-Va.) cause to sweat in a CD 10 race she is expected to prevail in.

In CD 2, the nation’s ultimate “median” district, Luria, a retired U.S. Navy commander, faces Republican challenger state Sen. Jen Kiggans (R-Virginia Beach), a former Navy helicopter pilot, in the first-ever congressional election between female military war veterans.

In CD 7, also regarded as a purple up-for-grabs swing district with a “vulnerable” Democratic incumbent, both candidates are also women who share similar career experiences with Spanberger and GOP challenger Yasli Vega both highlighting law enforcement backgrounds in their campaigns. 

Like Luria in CD 2 and Wexton in CD 10, Spanberger also must be reelected by a “new” constituency that includes more Republican voters after post-2020 Census reapportionment excluded areas of suburban Richmond that served as her base when she flipped CD 7 blue in 2018 and became the first Democrat to win the seat since the 1960s.

CPVI rates the district as “a toss-up.” FiveThirtyEight gauges CD 7 as “highly competitive” with a nominal +2 Democrat “lean.” Sabato’s “Crystal Ball” and Inside Elections give Spanberger a slight edge.

Polls appear to confirm projections of a nip-and-tuck race with an early August RMG Research survey of likely voters showing Spanberger polling 2 percentage points higher than Vega among respondents, a difference “barely out of the margins” of negligibility.

Elected Prince William Board supervisor in 2020, Vega is the Texas-born daughter of Salvadoran immigrants motivated as a teenager to become a law enforcement officer after her brother was shot by MS-13 gang members. 

Vega has served as an officer with the Alexandria and Manassas Park police departments and as a deputy with the Prince William Sheriff’s Office, where she remains an auxiliary deputy.

The chair of Republican Gov. Glenn Youngkin’s 2021 Latinos for Youngkin campaign, Vega emerged victorious from a contentious six-candidate GOP scrum on June 21 to earn the party’s CD 7 berth as the self-proclaimed “first conservative Hispanic to win a Republican congressional primary in Virginia.”

Spanberger, who was not tested in a primary also touts law enforcement credentials. The daughter of a federal law enforcement officer, she worked for more than four years as a U.S. Postal Inspection Service agent specializing in money laundering and narcotics cases before serving eight years with the CIA as an operations officer.

With both candidates prominently featuring their support for law enforcement, their campaigns are citing their opponent’s decencies in dedication to the cause in nearly $9 million of recent ad buys, including $4.7 million by Spanberger’s campaign, according to Federal Communications Commission filings compiled by the Virginia Public Access Project. 

A digital ad released in late August claims Vega “voted against our police and sheriffs” when she voted against annual budgets consecutive years as a Prince William County Board supervisor. 

“Yesli Vega won’t keep us safe,” the ad’s ending note says.

Spanberger has also been pounding away at Vega for saying Jan. 6 defendants are being unfairly persecuted and discrediting the FBI’s search of former President Donald Trump’s Mar-A-Lago resort-home, citing campaign fundraising emails where Vega says the “corrupt” search was “for no reason” and claims the FBI is part of the “deep state.” 

“I carried a gun every single day for a couple years,” she said in a statement. “I have written my fair share of search warrant, arrest warrant affidavits. I have a set of experiences as well. That’s why I find [Vega’s] position on commitment to law enforcement so frankly offensive.”

Vega does not support “defunding the FBI” but if elected, said she would call for an audit of the agency.

“Any person who would call FBI agents and law enforcement officers corrupt and deep state, that’s disqualifying,” Spanberger said.

Noting she was a vocal opponent of the party’s “defund the police” contingent, Spanberger’s campaign literature emphasizes she is a co-sponsor of a measure within the proposed Invest to Protect Act to boost federal grant funding for local police departments to hire and train more officers, which is popular with area police agencies.

Vega dismisses Spanberger’s attempts to discredit her law enforcement credentials as  “election-season Abby” reaching for “laughable” straws, noting the incumbent voted for the “George Floyd Justice in Policing Act,” which makes it easier to sue law enforcement.

Vega said she voted against overall Prince William County budgets, while pushing to hire more police officers, because the spending plans included tax increases she opposed during the pandemic and then during inflationary price increases she blames on the Biden administration and Democrats such as Spanberger,

A former hostage negotiator who appears in her auxiliary deputy uniform in campaign messages pledging to fight crime and illegal immigration at the U.S.-Mexico border, Vega held an Aug. 15 law-enforcement roundtable that discussed police officer staffing shortages and garnered her endorsements from more than half the district’s law enforcement agencies.

“Republicans, Democrats, and Independents all want to be safe in their own neighborhoods,” Vega says in a campaign statement.

“As your representative, I will never succumb to the defunding of, or the new term ‘reimagining of’ police and law enforcement. Whether it’s the cop on the street or the agent preventing fentanyl from crossing our southern border, I will always support, fund, and stand with the brave men and women of law enforcement who keep us safe.”