Mark McCloskey Won’t Have Guns or Money Returned, Despite Pardon, Missouri Judge Rules: Report

December 30, 2022 TruthUSA

St. Louis lawyer Mark McCloskey will not have his guns or the fines he paid returned to him even though he had received a governor’s pardon in 2021, a Missouri judge has ruled.

McCloskey and his wife, Patricia McCloskey, both personal injury lawyers, pleaded guilty in June 2021 to misdemeanor charges for assault and harassment, respectively, over an incident in 2020 where they had wielded guns in self defense at their property while watching Black Lives Matter protesters walk through their private, gated neighborhood.

They were required to pay maximum fines totaling $2,750. As part of the plea agreement, the two also surrendered the guns they wielded—a Colt AR-15 rifle and a Bryco pistol.

After their convictions, Missouri Gov.Mike Parson on July 30, 2021 pardoned the couple and shortly following the move, McCloskey filed a lawsuit in St. Louis City Circuit Court seeking to have the guns returned and the fines paid back to him and his wife.

Circuit Judge Joan Moriarty rejected the request on Dec. 28, saying that the governor’s pardon doesn’t have any impact on the plea agreement the couple had agreed to.

“Plaintiff and his wife are required to follow through with their end of the bargain,” she wrote, reported the St. Louis Post-Dispatch.

“While the governor’s pardon does clear plaintiff’s record of the conviction,” she added, “his guilt remains and the terms of an agreement that predicated said guilt also remains.”

McCloskey said he plans to appeal, the outlet reported.

In February 2022, the Missouri Supreme Court indefinitely suspended the McCloskeys’ law licenses. The court also stayed the suspension and put the two attorneys on probation for a year, which means they can still practice law but the suspension would kick in if they violate their probation by not following the “Rules of Professional Conduct.”

Alan Pratzel, the court’s chief disciplinary officer, previously filed a motion in court to have both Mark and Patricia’s licences suspended, KCUR-FM reported at the time. He said that while the governor’s pardons erased the McCloskeys’ convictions, in such cases “the person’s guilt remains.”

McCloskey in August 2022 lost to Missouri Attorney General Eric Schmitt in the Republican primary, after having filed papers in May 2021 to run for Missouri’s open U.S. Senate seat.