Senate Rejects Tough New Immigration Laws Similar to Trump’s
There was strong opposition from legal experts and community groups to the new immigration laws that could result in the imprisonment of individuals who refuse to cooperate with their deportation. The Australian government’s attempt to prevent a High Court ruling led to the Bill being referred to a Senate Committee for review. The Bill, if passed, would enforce prison sentences on those who resist deportation, re-examine protection findings for refugees, and block visa applications from countries that don’t accept the return of their citizens.
The Asylum Seekers Resource Centre and the Human Rights Law Centre criticized the Bill, likening it to policies of former U.S. President Donald Trump. They argued that the law was dangerous, unprecedented, and incompatible with Australia’s obligations under the 1951 Refugee Convention. Various community leaders and activists expressed concerns about the proposed legislation, citing its potential negative impact on vulnerable individuals.
Greens Senator David Shoebridge raised concerns about the sweeping powers granted to the immigration minister under the Bill, describing them as disproportionate and akin to “God-like powers.” Other senators, like Jacqui Lambie, urged a more cautious approach and advocated for thorough scrutiny of the Bill to ensure its effectiveness and fairness.
The Australian Law Council and Home Affairs also expressed reservations about the Bill, with the former urging MPs not to pass it due to its punitive nature. Home Affairs pointed out potential loopholes that could be exploited by people smugglers under the proposed legislation. Opposition spokespeople like James Paterson and Paul Scarr highlighted concerns raised by diaspora communities, emphasizing the need for clarity and fairness in the legislation to avoid unintended consequences.
Overall, there is significant opposition and skepticism surrounding the Bill, with MPs receiving hundreds of emails from concerned constituents. Calls for careful consideration, transparency, and fairness have been made to ensure that the legislation does not adversely affect individuals or communities seeking refuge or visiting Australia.
