States’ Reactions to the Opposition’s Nuclear Proposal as an Alternative to Achieving Net Zero
South Australia’s opposition leader, David Speirs, openly supported nuclear energy compared to other state leaders in Australia in response to the federal Opposition Leader Peter Dutton’s plan to construct seven nuclear power plants across the country if elected.
The Liberal-National Coalition is proposing to replace retiring coal-fired power stations with nuclear facilities as an alternative path towards net zero, instead of opting for a mass roll-out of wind turbines, solar panels, and batteries.
While most state Labor premiers have shown negative responses and Liberal Party opposition leaders have avoided openly supporting the concept, David Speirs from South Australia is an exception.
State governments have already invested millions in taxpayer funds towards renewable energy transitions.
Victoria
Victoria’s Premier Jacinta Allan is strongly against the Coalition’s nuclear plan, stating her opposition in a letter to Mr. Dutton.
She emphasized standing with the Victorian community, particularly in Gippsland, for a clean, secure, and affordable energy source.
Opposition State Liberal Leader John Pesutto had no plans for nuclear as a state opposition, leaving the door open for future discussions based on potential initiatives at a federal level.
Queensland
Queensland Premier Steven Miles has two main concerns about the proposal: nuclear waste and cost, preferring a plan that integrates renewable energies like solar, wind, and pumped hydro storage to achieve net zero emissions.
Mr. Miles expressed doubts over the federal government’s ability to obtain sites for nuclear power plants without the cooperation of his government.
New South Wales
Labor Premier Chris Minns cited cost, time constraints, and risks to consumers as reasons for not pushing to remove the state moratorium on nuclear energy.
NSW Opposition Leader Mark Speakman expressed openness to nuclear power subject to rigorous assessments.
South Australia
South Australia’s Premier Peter Malinauskas criticized the federal opposition for going against market economics, science, and evidence, citing concerns over potential cost increases associated with nuclear power.
Opposition Leader David Speirs showed explicit support for civil nuclear energy in South Australia, proposing a Royal Commission to explore its potential benefits for the state.
Western Australia
WA’s Energy Minister Reece Whitby dismissed the likelihood of nuclear power in Australia, highlighting the lack of legislative framework, workforce, and experience, as well as the substantial taxpayer subsidies required for implementation.
Opposition energy spokesperson Steve Thomas maintained an open stance on nuclear energy, emphasizing the necessity of a solid business case and community support before proceeding.
