Stop blaming racism in the housing market and start looking at your parents as the root cause
Commentary
There’s no shortage of bad ideas about how to fix Canada’s housing crisis. But what if time is short and you need to access all the bad ideas in one convenient location? Then make haste for the Office of the Federal Housing Advocate (FHA).
Over the past two years, Marie-Josée Houle, Canada’s first (and hopefully only) FHA, has established her office as Ottawa’s one-stop-shop for the worst possible advice on housing issues. Houle’s main obsession is with removing profit-making—or what she calls “financialization”—from Canada’s housing market.
Beyond forbidding anyone from making a living supplying accommodation to people who demand it, she also wants to make it impossible for landlords to evict tenants for almost any reason, impose a nationwide system of rent control, and grant homeless squatters virtual property rights over public parks.
But perhaps the most alarming of Houle’s many outrageous assertions and demands is that Canada’s housing market is rife with racism which, as a 2022 report claims, can only be eliminated by deliberate federal action. This FHA report calls for a public takeover of privately owned apartment buildings and a ban on banks or pension funds lending to any “financialized” housing providers.
Setting aside the catastrophic implications of such policies, what should we make of the underlying claim that Canada’s housing market is rigged against “racialized communities”? The FHA musters no credible evidence that racists control the buying, selling, or renting of housing in Canada. But ample data on race and housing from other sources tell a very different story.
- Let’s Stop Aligning with Radical Ideologies, says Peter Stockland
- Judge Denies Trump Subpoena Request for NBC Regarding Stormy Daniels Documentary